SMSMC Blog

Staff phones and patient information: the rules a small practice needs

What the HIPAA Security Rule asks of a practice whose staff use phones for scheduling, messages and photos, and the written rules that answer it.

By Jim Venuto

Phones arrived before the rules did

NIST’s 2018 guide to securing electronic health records on mobile devices (SP 1800-1, final July 2018; source) opens with a plain observation: healthcare providers use mobile devices to handle patient clinical information, and many adopted them before putting privacy and security safeguards in place. In a small practice the pattern is familiar. The front desk texts appointment details from a personal phone. A clinician photographs a wound for the chart. A manager checks the schedule from a phone that also holds a family photo library.

None of these is unreasonable. The privacy question is what the practice has decided about them, in writing, before one of those phones is lost.

What the Security Rule asks

The HIPAA Security Rule does not mention phones by name. It asks for a handful of things that phones trigger. Quotes and requirements below are from the Rule as published on eCFR.

  • A risk analysis. Section 164.308(a)(1)(ii)(A) requires an accurate and thorough assessment of the potential risks and vulnerabilities to electronic protected health information. If staff phones touch patient data, they belong in it.
  • Training. The same section requires a security awareness and training program for all members of the workforce, including management.
  • Ending access. It requires procedures for terminating access to electronic protected health information, which includes the phone of someone who leaves.
  • Device controls. Section 164.310(d) requires policies for the receipt and removal of hardware and electronic media, including final disposition and removal of electronic protected health information before reuse. Keeping a record of who has which device is addressable.
  • Encryption. Section 164.312 lists encryption of stored information and an automatic logoff after inactivity as addressable, and encryption in transmission “whenever deemed appropriate.” Under section 164.306(d)(3), addressable does not mean optional: the practice must assess each one, implement it if reasonable and appropriate, and otherwise document why not and use an equivalent measure.

Encryption also decides what a loss costs. The definition of unsecured protected health information in section 164.402 is information not rendered unusable, unreadable or indecipherable to unauthorized persons through a technology the Secretary specifies. If a lost phone’s patient data was not protected that way, the breach notification rules can apply, subject to the practice’s assessment of the incident. When a breach is confirmed, individuals must be told without unreasonable delay and no later than 60 calendar days after discovery (section 164.404). A breach affecting fewer than 500 people is reported to the Secretary within 60 days after the end of the calendar year; 500 or more is reported at the same time as the individual notice (section 164.408).

Rules to write down

These are the practice’s answers to the questions above. They are advice, not requirements in the Rule’s text.

  1. Which phones may hold patient information. Choose: practice-owned phones only, or personal phones under defined conditions. NIST’s mobile device guidance, SP 800-124 Rev. 2 (final May 2023; source), covers both organization-provided and personally owned devices, so the decision is yours, but make it once and write it down.
  2. A screen lock and encryption on any phone that touches the schedule, messages or records. Require a passcode and automatic lock. Check that device encryption is on; the definition of unsecured information above turns on whether the data was rendered unreadable.
  3. What may be sent by text. Decide whether appointment reminders, test results or photos go by ordinary text, a secure messaging tool, or not at all. Whatever you choose, tell patients how you will contact them.
  4. Where photos live. A photo taken in the phone’s camera app can land in a personal cloud account. Name the one approved place for clinical photos, and delete the original from the phone after upload.
  5. What happens on a loss. Name who is called first, who can lock or wipe the phone, and who decides whether notification is required. Keep the phone’s owner and model in a list so the answer is quick.
  6. What happens on departure. The termination procedure includes removing practice accounts and data from the phone before the last day.

Who does what

  • The practice’s privacy and security lead owns the rules, the device list and the risk analysis entry.
  • The practice owner approves which phones may hold patient information and signs off on any exception.
  • Each staff member reads the rules at hire and once a year, reports a lost phone the same hour, and keeps patient photos out of personal accounts.

The training requirement is where a one-page rule becomes behavior. A short yearly session using the practice’s own list of approved phones teaches more than a generic video.

Sources