SMSMC Blog

Old client files are a liability: a retention schedule a small firm can build in an afternoon

Records a firm no longer needs can still be stolen. How a tax or accounting practice sets a retention schedule, with the federal rule that already requires one.

By Jim Venuto

A settlement that started with one email

On October 20, 2025, the New York Attorney General announced a $60,000 settlement with an accounting firm. A phishing email led to ransomware, the firm’s systems held clients’ Social Security numbers without encryption, and it took about a year and a half for the people affected to be told.

Much of what a small firm loses in an incident like that is data it no longer used: returns from clients who left years ago, scanned identity documents, old payroll files. None of it earns anything. All of it has to be protected, and all of it has to be reported if it is exposed.

The rule already in place

Tax preparers are “financial institutions” under the FTC Safeguards Rule (16 CFR 314.2(h)(2)(viii)). The rule requires a firm to have procedures to securely dispose of customer information no later than two years after the last date it was used to provide a service to that customer, unless the firm needs it for business operations or another legitimate business purpose, the law requires it to be kept, or targeted disposal is not reasonably feasible because of how it is stored (16 CFR 314.4(c)(6)(i)). The firm must also review its retention policy periodically (16 CFR 314.4(c)(6)(ii)).

In practice that means “we keep everything” is not a policy. Each kind of record needs a reason to be kept and a date when it goes.

Building the schedule

Block one afternoon and a spreadsheet with five columns: record type, where it lives, why it is kept, how long, and who deletes it.

  1. List the record types, not the files. Returns and workpapers, engagement letters, identity documents, bank and payroll records, e-signature and portal records, email attachments. A small firm usually ends up with ten to fifteen rows.
  2. Write down every place each one lives. The tax software, the document portal, the shared drive, email, the scanner’s storage, backups, and staff laptops. The places nobody remembers are where old data sits longest.
  3. Give each row its reason and its period. Where a law or a professional rule sets a period, name it in the row. Where only the firm’s own needs apply, say so, and keep the period as short as the work allows. Anything with no reason gets the two-year disposal date.
  4. Mark the exceptions explicitly. A client in an audit or dispute, a legal hold, a record the firm is required to keep. An exception is a decision with a name and a date on it, not a default.
  5. Decide how deletion happens. For electronic records and old drives, NIST SP 800-88 Revision 2 (September 2025) describes sanitization methods matched to the type of media. For a small firm the usual answers are the deletion features of its own software and portal, and certified destruction for retired drives and paper.
  6. Put the review on the calendar. Once a year, after filing season, run the schedule: delete what has passed its date, confirm the exceptions still apply, and update the rows if a new tool has been added.

Who does what

  • The owner or managing partner decides the periods and signs off on the exceptions. This is a business decision, not an IT one.
  • The IT provider finds where the data actually lives, turns on retention settings where the software supports them, and handles backups and drive destruction.
  • Staff stop saving client documents to their own desktops and email folders, because those copies never reach the schedule.

A firm that holds two years of former clients’ records instead of ten has less to protect, a smaller notice to send if something goes wrong, and a written answer when a regulator or an insurer asks how it handles disposal.

Sources