No-cost assessment tools from CISA and CIS for schools, towns and small agencies, reviewed
A side-by-side review of CSET, CISA Cyber Hygiene scanning, the CPG 2.0 goals and CIS CSAT for school districts, towns and small public agencies, with what changed at MS-ISAC.
A school breach that started with one login
In December 2024, attackers used a compromised login to reach PowerSchool’s customer support portal, and the account reportedly lacked multi-factor authentication. Districts then reported what had been taken: Rochester City School District said 134,000 students were affected, and Toronto’s district board put its figure at close to 1.5 million. The attacker claimed records on more than 62 million students and 9.5 million teachers, a number PowerSchool said it could not confirm.
Two years earlier, CISA’s congressionally mandated K-12 report, Protecting Our Future, had already named the basic problem. Its finding was that schools need resources, simplicity and prioritization, and its first recommendation was to invest in the most impactful measures first, with multi-factor authentication among the starting priorities. Its second was to recognize resource constraints and use no-cost and low-cost services.
That second recommendation is the subject of this review. Schools, towns, fire districts, libraries and small authorities can get a credible picture of their security posture for no license cost. The catch is knowing which free tool answers which question.
What changed in 2025 and 2026
Before choosing a tool, know that one of the most familiar free resources changed. CISA’s cooperative agreement with the Center for Internet Security (CIS) ended, and on October 1, 2025, the Multi-State Information Sharing and Analysis Center (MS-ISAC) moved to a fee-based membership model. CIS says non-members are being offboarded in phases and that membership is now required to buy add-on services such as Albert and MDBR+.
Some things stay free to state, local, tribal and territorial (SLTT) governments without MS-ISAC membership, according to CIS: CIS SecureSuite, CIS Benchmarks, CIS-CAT, the CIS Controls Navigator, the Ransomware Business Impact Analysis tool and the TLP:CLEAR threat intelligence feed. Route Fifty reported in February 2026 that governmental organizations with an annual operating budget under $25 million can get a first year of membership free through a hardship waiver, and that MS-ISAC Connect, a peer-community tier, is free to any organization.
If your district or town relied on MS-ISAC for incident response or managed services, confirm your status directly with CIS rather than assuming coverage continues.
The four tools, side by side
| Tool | Question it answers | Who can use it | Effort |
|---|---|---|---|
| CISA Cyber Hygiene Vulnerability Scanning | What can an attacker see from the internet right now? | SLTT governments and public and private critical infrastructure | Low: one email, then weekly reports |
| CISA Cross-Sector Cybersecurity Performance Goals (CPG 2.0) | Are we doing the baseline practices that matter most? | Voluntary; aimed at small and medium organizations | Low to moderate: a structured self-check |
| CISA Cyber Security Evaluation Tool (CSET) | How do we score against a recognized standard, with a report to show for it? | Tagged for schools, SLTT, small business, industry | Moderate: install and answer questions |
| CIS Controls Self Assessment Tool (CIS CSAT) | How far along are we on the CIS Controls, and who owns each gap? | Free hosted web app, any organization | Moderate to high: team-based tracking |
CISA Cyber Hygiene Vulnerability Scanning
What it is. A no-cost service in which CISA continuously scans your internet-facing assets on public, static IPv4 addresses. A companion Web Application Scanning service checks public web apps for common flaws, including the OWASP Top Ten.
What you get. Weekly vulnerability reports, ad-hoc alerts for urgent findings, and monthly web application reports. CISA says service usually begins within three business days of signup, with reports expected within two weeks of the scan start date. You sign up by emailing CISA with the subject line given on its Cyber Hygiene page.
Limits. It sees only what faces the internet. It does not look at laptops, internal servers, cloud identity settings or your policies. It also produces findings, not fixes: someone still has to patch.
Who it fits. Every eligible town, district and agency. Low effort, continuous, and it shows you the exposed systems an outsider can already see.
CISA CPG 2.0 as a self-check
What it is. CISA’s voluntary baseline of security practices for critical infrastructure organizations of all sizes, aimed especially at small and medium organizations. Version 2.0, released in December 2025, aligns the goals to the NIST Cybersecurity Framework (CSF) 2.0 functions, adds a Govern function focused on leadership accountability, and merges IT and operational technology goals.
What you get. A short list of goals, each rated by CISA for cost, impact and ease of implementation. That rating is the useful part for a small agency: it tells you which gaps are cheap and high-value. CISA planned an updated CPG 2.0 checklist alongside a CSET module.
Limits. It is a baseline, not a full program. Answering “yes” to a goal is self-reported; nothing verifies it. Some goals assume IT staff that a small library or water district may not have.
Who it fits. Leadership teams and boards that want a one-sitting conversation about the basics, and anyone who needs to show “we followed the federal baseline” to an insurer or state oversight body.
CISA Cyber Security Evaluation Tool (CSET)
What it is. A free desktop application from CISA that walks you through a structured assessment of IT and industrial control system practices against recognized government and industry standards. CISA’s page lists educational institutions, SLTT governments and small and medium businesses among its audiences.
What you get. Scored reports you can keep and repeat. The current release, version 13.0, includes CPG 2.0 with a setting for IT, OT or both, and CPG reports now include answer heatmaps. It also carries updated modules for NIST SP 800-53, SP 800-171 and others.
Limits. CSET 13.0 retired several older assessment types, including the Ransomware Readiness Assessment and the Cyber Resilience Review; existing assessments still open, but new ones cannot be created. The release notes advise creating any still-needed retired assessment before upgrading. The tool is only as honest as the person answering, and a full standards module takes real time.
Who it fits. An IT lead or consultant who wants a documented, repeatable score against CPG 2.0 or a named standard, especially for a utility, transit or water function with operational technology.
CIS Controls Self Assessment Tool (CIS CSAT)
What it is. A free, CIS-hosted web application for tracking and prioritizing implementation of the CIS Controls. CIS describes it as usable by organizations of any size. An on-premises edition, CSAT Pro, was folded into the CIS SecureSuite Platform in October 2025.
What you get. For each control and safeguard, you record documentation, implementation, automation and reporting status. The first person to register becomes the owner and can add team members, so gaps can be assigned to named people.
Limits. It assumes you are using the CIS Controls as your framework; mapping results to NIST CSF 2.0 takes extra work. Tracking every safeguard is more effort than a small office may sustain, so start with the subset that matches your size.
Who it fits. Districts and towns with at least one IT staffer or a managed service provider, who want a living gap list rather than a one-time score.
How to use them together
- This week: sign up for Cyber Hygiene scanning. It costs nothing and works without your effort after setup.
- This month: run a CPG 2.0 self-check with leadership in the room. Use CISA’s cost and impact ratings to pick three gaps to close first. Multi-factor authentication on every remote and vendor login should be one of them.
- This quarter: run CSET against CPG 2.0 to produce a scored baseline you can repeat next year, or set up CIS CSAT if your IT team prefers a tracked gap list.
- Ongoing: check your MS-ISAC status and the hardship waiver, and read CISA’s K-12 toolkit if you run a school system.
| Role | Owns |
|---|---|
| Superintendent, town supervisor or executive director | Approving the self-check and the priority list |
| IT lead or managed service provider | Scan sign-up, CSET or CSAT, remediation |
| Business office | Vendor contracts that require multi-factor authentication and security by default |
When to get help
If the self-check turns up more gaps than your staff can close, or you need someone to turn a CSET report into a budget request your board can act on, an outside review can set the order of work.
Want to talk it through? Book a free 30-minute call with Security Medic Consulting.
Sources
- TechCrunch, PowerSchool begins notifying students and teachers after massive data breach, January 28, 2025 (accessed 2026-10-29).
- CISA, CISA Releases Protecting Our Future: Partnering to Safeguard K-12 Organizations from Cybersecurity Threats, January 24, 2023 (accessed 2026-10-29).
- CISA, Protecting Our Future: Partnering to Safeguard K-12 Organizations from Cybersecurity Threats (accessed 2026-10-29).
- Center for Internet Security, MS-ISAC Membership FAQ (accessed 2026-10-29).
- Route Fifty, It’s not over: Cyber info-sharing center begins next chapters after losing federal funding, February 24, 2026 (accessed 2026-10-29).
- CISA, Cyber Hygiene Services (accessed 2026-10-29).
- CISA, Cross-Sector Cybersecurity Performance Goals (accessed 2026-10-29).
- Utility Dive, CISA updates cybersecurity benchmarks for critical infrastructure organizations, December 15, 2025 (accessed 2026-10-29).
- CISA, Cyber Security Evaluation Tool (CSET) (accessed 2026-10-29).
- CISA on GitHub, CSET releases (accessed 2026-10-29).
- Center for Internet Security, CIS CSAT: free tool for assessing implementation of CIS Controls (accessed 2026-10-29).